Sunday, September 21, 2014

If flawsaphor chooses .....!

Ten Amazing Books

It is very difficult for anyone – well-read or otherwise – to choose 10 or 20 books as the best they have read and make it as public too. Such actions are always fraught with the danger of one missing out prominent or popular book or even nominating less deserving ones. But given the highly individualistic nature of action involved, the level of subjectivity can never be wiped out. It is all the more difficult for people like me, being in the kind of profession I am in, it is a Himalayan task. People in my trade inevitably read thousands of words day in and day out – covering a wide range of subjects. So, making a list of best 10 books is almost impossible given the sheer range of subjects we are exposed to given each one of us tend to read books in the subjects we love more than others.
Through three and a half decades that I have been reading books on a constant basis, one thing most irritating is people coming up, every now and then, with posts like “The 10 books that shaped my life” or some such similar mindless stuff. Can books alone shape one’s life? Books are part of any given culture and one of the many tools that shape a person’s life and career. Again, when the word ‘Culture’ is uttered people tend to think of many gaseous and vacuous stuff. The habits, mores, customs, practices, value systems, institutions, societal tools, laws and many more comprise culture. Given all these, such claims are nothing but a pretentious, attention grabbing techniques.

So, here I am choosing 10 books among thousands that attracted me most – though they might not have had even 1% impact on my life and thinking pattern and ability. I am choosing these just for the sheer ability to arouse curiosity and interest.
      
               1)   Dialogues of Plato –translated and edited by Benjamin Jowett 



If there is a sheer joy and happiness in written words [mention irony!], they are in these dialogues. It is amazing to even conceive that people who lived thousands of years ago discussed the fundamental problems of human living thread bare and the dialogues have withstood the test of time and changing value systems. Bertrand Russell corrupted my mind and I may tend to believe with Russell in the superiority of Plato’s imagination and the dialogues could be a book of fiction, yet this remains one of the foremost books that will arouse curiosity and logical thinking in young minds.



2)  Gay Science by Nietzsche - translated and edited by Walter Kauffman


This book has become popular by the atheists and agnostics from all over the world for about a century now for the famous “God is Dead.” But these claims stem more from defective understanding of the book and inability to comprehend the thread. I know people will throw stones at me, but I stick my neck out and cling on to what I am telling. Aphorisms, scathing assessment of luminaries and throwing light on humanness, this book has all that and much more. Whether this was the precursor to “Thus Spake Zarathustra” or its sequel, the book remains my favorite.




3)    Commentaries on Living series by Jiddu Krishnamurti 




If there is someone who is most misunderstood and most underrated thinker, then it has to be JK. In this series and throughout his lifetime, he comprehended much in advance the lives human beings would be leading in the digital and mechanical era, rapidly declining value systems and deterioration of reasoning and pleaded with the listeners in one talk after another. Yet none of us seem to have listened to him – at all. The lives we are leading is an ample testimony to that.






4)    Surely You’re Joking Mr Feynman

This is one book from the title to last page that captivates the imagination of the readers. As such it is a simple book that records the adventures of Feynman through his life, his remarkable insights in the working of physics and the laws of nature etc. But the success of this book lies in the fact that every single reader wanted to open the safes, drink tea with lemon and cream, investigate every disaster of the machines and all such adventures of Feynman. Every travel junkie harried around to find more about Tannu Tuva and yearned to visit this remote land after reading Sure You’re Joking, Tuva or Bust and the Last Journey. Feynman broke the myth that scientists have to be mysterious and serious and this book highlights a fundamental truth that any proper understanding of Nature and expressions of such an understanding have to be simple so that any layman can understand them. 

5)    Godel, Escher, Bach – An Eternal Golden Braid by Douglas Hofstadter


If there is one book after reading which a youngster would emerge more knowledgeable than ever before, it is this one. Taking common themes from the works of Godel, Escher and Bach, Hofstadter tears into the foundations of intelligence, meaning, symmetry and almost whole of life – how cognition, intelligence and communication are possible. As the book progresses, every page is a treat with breathtaking paintings of Escher, koans, general puzzles and emerging new meanings and patterns of life. After the book, every reader is bound to view every dimension of life from a new angle. One word – Exhilarating.


6) The Self and its Brain – by Popper and Eccles


Simply put, this is a book that talks about interaction between body and mind, how biological and chemical processes impact thoughts, behavior etc. It would have ended up as one of the countless boring philosophical debates but for the individual brilliance of Karl Popper and John Eccles. Dividing the book into three parts, Popper deals first with the world of objects – the phenomena, Eccles, the acclaimed neurophysiologist, with the neurological understanding of thoughts, emotions etc and the final part is the dialogue between the philosopher and the neurophysiologist. This is a very fundamental book but a very important one for understanding dualism that asks very significant questions such as how life emerged from matter among others. But the sub-title of the book “an Argument for Interactionism” gives away what is the fundamental problem with the western thought. Unlike Hindu philosophies which treat mind, thoughts etc as physical, whole lot of European philosophies have treated mind, thoughts and emotions as something apart from physical world. This problem is beyond Popper and Eccles, yet this is a very significant conversation from about 40 years ago.


7)     The man who mistook his wife for a hat – Oliver Sachs




In this book of 24 remarkable essays featuring the descriptions of case histories of some of his patients, Sachs takes us through a journey of enchanting and yet frightening world of people with abnormal faculty functioning and yet very sad in real life. In the centuries that went by these people would have been dismissed as possessed by evil and in some cultures would have been beaten to death. 






8)    Bhaarathiyaar Kavithaigal





This is one of the most captivating and energizing poetry collections that one can ever lay one’s hands upon. To me personally it is one of the eternal fountains of creativity compressed into few lines of poetry. Nothing more. Go read and get inspired!





9)     The Secret Doctrine by Madame Blavatsky



There is a running joke that if there is one book that no human ever completed including its author, it has to be Secret Doctrine by Blavatsky. It is a mammoth book with tall claims, with equally stunning range of subjects covered, from philosophy to religion to occultism to science and evolution of races, and extraordinary details. Even discounting the subjects covered in the book, I doubt whether any human being other than Blavatsky knew so many languages, had such in-depth knowledge of the lost civilizations and remarkable foray into future and distant planets in the solar system and beyond. From Atlantis and Lemuria to life in Venus this book covers a vast range of interesting postulations with intricate details and elaborate footnotes. Major sections are really boring but proem and those sections dealing with remote cultures and civilizations are really interesting. But I doubt the book indeed achieves the claim it makes – wedding religion and modern science.


10)     The History of Dharma Shastra by P.V. Kane


Kane wrote this magnum opus of his over three decades! This book in five volumes is a rare collection and interpretation of evolution of social codes and laws through two thousand years in India. From the worship of stones on the road to highest philosophies, from the role of law texts in the lives of ordinary people to rules governing the rulers, from the controversies concerning the existence of multiple texts and authors to evolution and creation of modern Indian law, from greatest poetries of India to religious schools and monasteries – there is nothing about India that this book does not touch upon. For me the greatest strength of this book is neutral analysis of all the topics it covers – caste system, the role of so called scriptures in the lives of people, beef eating, astrology, astronomy, so on and so forth. This one book has been the launch pad of thousands of books on all the topics it covers. As Olivelle observed, it is the single most telling contribution by any individual in India from the medieval times onwards.

{ { {{ { { {{ { { {{ { { {{ { { {{

As I said in the beginning it is inevitable that many good books would get unmentioned. May be there are 100 more such books. However, time and health permitting, I may write few lines in near future about

1.      The Emperor’s New Mind: Concerning Computers, Minds and 
the Laws of Physics by Roger Penrose

2.     The Society of Mind by Marvin Minsky

3.     Morphic Resonance: The nature of formative causation by Rupert Sheldrake

4.     Myth of Invariance: The origin of Gods, Mathematics and Music 
by Ernest McClain

5.    Collected Works of Baba Saheb Ambedkar

6.     The biological and historical significance of Vedic mythology 
by A.K. Bhattacharyya

7.     One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

8.     Ulladu Naarpadhu by Ramana Maharshi

9.     An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding by David Hume

10.                       Adi Shankara's commentary of Bhagavad Gita

11.    The Second Sex by Simone de Beauvoir


Tuesday, July 15, 2014

Some Random Thoughts in தமிழ்


மானுடம்


வந்த வழி அறியாது
சென்ற வழி புரியாது
பிருட்டங்களின்
நிழல்களைத் தேடும்
மிருகக் கும்பல்


அண்ணாமலை


மா மலை
மருந்து மலை
ஞானத் தபோதனரை
வா வாவென்று அழைத்த மலை
அண்ணாமலை
தேவி கல்லோத்தரையில்
ஜப தப பூசை புனஸ்காரங்களை
தவிர்த்தல் நலம் என நல்கிய
சிவனையே
சடங்குச் சாமானாக
மாற்றியது பக்தர்கள் கூட்டம்


பிரமிள்


மொழியற்ற, சாதியற்ற, மதமற்ற
உண்மையை காணத் துடித்த அவனை
இந்த உலகம் புரிந்து கொள்ளவில்லை
அவனுக்கும் இவ்வுலகம் புரியவில்லை
நீட்ஷேவின் வாக்கு பொல்லாததுதான்
பாவம்
அவனை மற்றும் தாக்கிற்று


நான்


காலையில் வரும் பால் காரருக்கு
கணக்காளர்  வூட்டம்மா
தாலி கட்டினவருக்கு
மனைவி
பிள்ளைகளுக்கு
அம்மா
என் பெற்றோர்களுக்கு
மகள்
கூடப் பிறந்தவர்களுக்கு
அக்கா / தங்கை
சேர்ந்து பணி புரிபவர்களுக்கு
"கொலீக்"
ஆனால்
பார்வதி, அத்தை, மாமி, ஆண்டி,
என்று
தினம் தினம் நான் எடுக்கும் அவதாரங்கள் அநேகம்
ஆனால்
நான் யார்?
பெயரா? உடலா? உறவுகளா? சம்பந்தங்களா?
நான் யார்?
தீராத கேள்விக் குறி

?????????????








Wednesday, May 28, 2014

We Tāmilarā are not fanatical!!!!!!

We Tāmilarā are not fanatical!!!!!!

It is not surprising that Tamils are loved all over the world. In Northern India especially Tamils are loved for their genial and gregarious nature, wit, intelligence and more than anything for their law-abiding nature. But, invariably among people of other communities beyond the borders of Tamil Nadu if there is one thing people don’t like that is associated with all the Tamils, it is their love of their language.

Yes, surprisingly, over past two decades many a native speaker of other languages of India have told me and on and off written in vernacular languages – these Tamil chaps take their love and affinity to their mother tongue to the level of fanaticism.

Last year in a meeting of the doyens of Indian literature [among them were Jnanpith award winners and who’s who of Indian literary scene], many of them told me that while Tamilians are role models in preserving and promoting the mother tongue, they don’t approve of fanaticism. I am no body in front of those doyens. So, I quietly listened to them as they went on and on.

Some people even went to the extent of saying this ‘fanaticism’ of Tamils and Tamil nationalism of 20th century are sowing disruptive seeds among other communities and showing definitively a wrong way. Unanimously they all are of the opinion that Tamil Nationalism and ‘Tamil only’ was the first of its kind and while there are some positives to be taken away in the approach, the fanatical element is the impediment to knowing other cultures and ways of living.

How accurate and correct are these perceptions? I want to give many examples but limit myself to a case where there are no ambiguities and that which is beyond dispute.

First and foremost, in the last 500 years [any period less than that loses value in the minds of modern ‘intellectuals’ – LOL!], Tamilians were not the first or alone to reject the influence and usage of Sanskrit and Hindustani languages!

Much before the advent of early 20th century Tamil nationalism even took the seed form, there was a cyclone sweeping entire Bengal [entire = including present day Bangladesh].

Coinciding with the rise of Raja Ram Mohan Roy, loud whispers began to emerge all over Bengal as to the usage of Sanskrit and Hindi and the ensuing corruption of the original Bengali. By 1850s the whispers were turning out to be loud roars. The turn of events in the next ten years quietened down things a bit. But not for long and by this time journals (!!!!) have started and people were writing in pure Bengali.

Furious debates took the centre stage on the ‘acceptable style’ of Bengali writing and almost all the periodicals that were in vogue voiced their opinions. Two strong and warring sides, Sanskritpanthi (proponents of Sanskrit usage) and Banglapanthi (proponents of Bengali usage) were at loggerheads.

Raging debates saw plenty of acrimony and sarcasm spewed on air like never before. At one point it even threatened to split Bengal into three. Then came along Bankim Chandra!

He wrote a superb essay "Bangla Bhasha" in Bangadarshan [1285 Jaishta / May-June, 1883] and dismissed the Sanskritpanthi as Prachinponthi (backward looking), but did not completely support the Banglapanthi and he pointed out the perils of ‘only Bengali’ thought process.

He advocated the middle-path, the path aimed at enriching the still evolving Bengali language by using pure Bengali wherever possible and at the same time retaining Sanskrit words wherever necessary. The situation demanded that kind of authority and scholarliness. It is unbelievable that Bengalis, who are one of the most argumentative in the world, took his word and settled the dispute once for all. They had run-ins with English, Hindi and Urdu / Persian at various times in the 20th century but had wonderful guide rule to settle down in the middle path.

These events are recorded facts. Given that it is remarkable that even the most well-read people from all over India hold on to such false assumptions – even Bengalis.

Without doubt, part of Tamil renaissance in 20th century took casteist dimensions but that was part of higher anthropic principle in operation at that over Tamil Nadu. Struggles between various castes and communities will go on, but when it comes to Tamil Language nationalism, the intentions were not fanatical.

The intentions and actions are about resisting what my beloved friend on Twitter @dagalti wrote

#மதுரமல்லிமதுரமல்லிமதுரமல்லிமதுரமல்லி    

*I have selected and edited a fine English translation of Bankim’s “Bangla Bhasha” and it will appear in June or July issue of Indian Literature journal. Those who are interested can buy that and read.

Sunday, May 11, 2014

To Be Natural Is the Best Form of Discipline

It has become a norm, a standard, a trend over last seven or eight decades to look down upon the alternate lifestyles, especially that of those who are prone to wander around jobless and those who lean towards spiritual practices at a very young age disregarding the established patterns of leading a life. Invariably the elders advise these ‘vagabonds’ to ‘settle down’ in life. By ‘settling’ down it is assumed and understood the life style where a person should go to work, earn money, mate with the opposite sex and beget children. Further lectures would be on the way if one were to resist this advice on any grounds. And those lectures would always be accompanied by a finishing touch – this is the norm laid down and followed by human societies for thousands of years. Curious!
Equally curious are the opposition, especially in the last decade and half, to this stand on alternate lifestyles. More often than not, modern people to rubbish the opposition to alternate lifestyles as ignorance soaked ‘traditional’ thinking or deep rooted ‘religious evil’.  Even Swami Vivekananda, who felt that Indians are leading a routine, timid lives and have become pre-dominantly vegetarian [how wrong he was / is!] society and lays the blame squarely on the heads of Jainism and Buddhism. This mentality has led to incredible shrinking of space in modern Indian literature to vagabonds and hipsters and the number of works focusing on alternate lifestyles has become very negligible.
India and many civilizations have had rich history of people who do not fit into any fixed category as a householder or student or business person or a mendicant etc. So, the opposition to such behaviour is based on religion or religious practices? I do not know what religion that people are referring to. If you take Hinduism, right from Rig Veda [where ‘vatarasanas’ among others are eulogized] to Upanishads [there is even one called as Parivrajakopanishad] to Puranas and extraordinary number of references to vagabonds / nomads in the vernacular language works. In Jainism, from Rishabha Deva [the founder] to Mahavira and through centuries we find a religion dominated by the wanderers and ascetics. In Buddhism, right from Buddha and his sangha to 20th century works, the religion is full of wanderers and Buddhist travellers. In Christianity, from Christ to nameless wanderers and wayfarers who took the message of God in musical form to remote corners of their countries, we find a religion full of such people. So is the same with Islam.
Here, I have been careful not to mention those group of people in all the cultures who were not very religious in a conventional sense but practitioners of various spiritual practices. Reasons are obvious to be stated here again.
If religion is not the base for looking down upon the alternate lifestyles and vagabonds, then could it be the traditional, local cultural practices sans religion were behind such an outlook? I doubt so. Even in India, a much maligned country as being too religious, we have had hordes of wanderers in every nook and corner of the country for centuries. They were never maligned. Rather, at times, they were patronized and eulogized. Bauls of Bengal, Pathis of Uttar Pradesh, Meenas of Rajasthan and Haryana, Siddhas and Bhagavatas of Tamil Nadu and Andhra, Paridhis of Maharashtra and Karnataka give us ample testimony for their existence within societies. They were not born as such, but were classified later on based on their nomadic behaviours. It is British rulers who were allergic to these wanderers branded many of them as thieves, tribes, riff-raffs and so on in their attempts to ‘teach’ culture and civilized behaviour to desis.
Then what leads to such an outlook? Wandering life has got its own charm and glamour without any burdens of life that the rest of us endure. But it is highly vulnerable and dangerous. There is no security and comfort in leading such a life though it is devoid of burdens and responsibilities. The old age is very cruel for the wanderers. So, it is natural for the parents [especially those of 20th century where the dynamics of living and economics changed beyond recognition] to have a fear that if allowed one vagabond may lure 100s of their young ones. It is this fear of loss and natural concern of the grown-ups for the welfare and safety of their young ones drove them to a rigid stand of rubbishing and banishing all wanderers as undesirable and dangerous.
The same fear lies at the root of the adults when confronted with the so-called ‘modern’ issue of homosexuality and other ‘offbeat’ behaviours. Ruth Vanita has compiled two wonderful books on the same sex love and marriage from ancient India downwards. Word is that the third in the series may also appear sometime soon. Please go, buy and read those books, especially the ones cited in them. I do not agree with many of the things contained in the books, but she has done wonderful compilations. I need not write as what is the point of repeating that which is already there in the public domain? Reading those is very essential, especially for the youngsters who are all likely to be confronted by these issues. They should deviate from their elders by equipping themselves with knowledge rather than blindly acting out of passion. After all, to be honest, this phenomenon has been there for a long time. Were those people banished from the societies in the centuries before us? No.
Another important book in relation to all this is Ghumakkar Shastra.  As I was writing a critical evaluation, last week, of famous Indian polymath, writer and critic Rahul Sankrityayan for a vernacular journal, I was appalled at seeing a number of opinions that Sankrityayan wrote all such books only as a response to various anti-vagrancy acts that were being enacted in India during the middle of 20th century. Nothing could be farther from truth than this. One Sankrityayan was too great a scholar to be writing such serious books in response to some stupid non-enforceable laws being enacted by states. Second, his Volga se Ganga was written much before the acts came into existence. He wrote those works simply to de-mythify the very outlook I have been talking here.  In these works Sankrityayan heavily romanticizes the offbeat behaviours, vagrancy and other modes of existence within a human society. He was not advocating renunciation; he was not eulogizing proper sannyasins but Vagabonds, especially in Ghumakkar Shastra [in Tamil ஊர் சுற்றி புராணம் ; in English Treatise on Vagabondage; translations are available in almost all the Indian languages and French and German too] where he makes virtue out of vagrancy, aimless wandering and all related stuff. It is an extreme book where he goes to the length of arguing for the separation of children [both boys and girls] at a very young age and set out for roaming around.
Another book is The Wayfarers, a monumental collection by William Donkin of what he termed as masts [not those who renounced the world, not religious people, but spiritually enlightened vagabonds] in India. It contains details of such people in every nook and corner of India. It is a painful book to read and offers no tangible purpose and usefulness to the reader. Yet, it is a constant reminder that such people did and continue to occupy ‘our’ space and along with us.
I always had and continue to have a dim opinion of the philosophical works of DK (and his chelas too), but he was something that was needed at that time in India. He was a quintessential hipster. He was the guy who loved getting under the skin of as many as possible. He wore bathroom slippers while coming to International Conferences; smoked beedis in pipe holder; pouted contradictory views on almost everything but filled with carefully chosen expletives; roamed the world with the eunuchs, gays, prostitutes. But beneath all the facades he was a scholar and we all remember him for that and not his vagrant behaviour.
          So, dear modern ‘intellectuals’, please do not rubbish the fears and concerns of your elders as ‘traditional’, ‘religious’ and ‘close minded’ stupidities. The elders, please do not thrust your fears and concerns beyond a point on your young ones. For fear constricts the personalities, not only yours but also that of your young ones. Let them be natural. If they can be as they are and natural without deceiving anyone through their lives, that is the best for them and the society in which they are going to live. That is the best, disciplined life you can offer them. As Ramana Maharishi once wrote 

“To be natural is the best form of discipline.”